Why Is My Banana Pudding Runny? (Easy Solutions Here)

Have you ever made a batch of banana pudding, only to discover it’s a bit too runny when it comes out of the fridge? If so, you’re not alone! Many home cooks have experienced this same problem–but don’t despair, because there are some easy solutions to make sure your banana pudding turns out perfect every time.

In this article, we’ll explore why your banana pudding might be runny, and how you can fix it.

So, let’s get started!

Why Is My Banana Pudding Runny?

If you find that your banana pudding is runny, it may be due to not thickening it enough.

Pudding is a custard-like dessert that requires you to combine milk, sugar, and a thickening agent like cornstarch, and then simmer it over low heat until it thickens.

If the pudding isn’t cooked for long enough, it will remain thin and runny.

Another possible cause of runny banana pudding is not allowing it to chill properly.

This is especially true for no-cook puddings, which require you to mix the ingredients and then chill for several hours before serving.

If it isn’t sufficiently chilled, the pudding will remain thin and runny.

In addition, too much liquid can also cause your banana pudding to be runny.

If you use too much milk or cream, or too much banana puree or other type of fruit puree, the pudding will be thin and runny.

To avoid a runny banana pudding, it is important to follow the recipe closely.

Make sure you simmer the pudding until it thickens, and allow it to chill for the suggested amount of time.

Additionally, make sure to measure your ingredients accurately, as too much liquid can lead to a runny pudding.

Will Banana Pudding Thicken In Fridge?

Banana pudding can thicken in the refrigerator, as the cold temperature helps set the pudding and produce a firmer texture.

Generally, this process occurs over a few hours.

The rate of thickening will vary depending on the type of pudding you are making; pre-made pudding mixes will usually thicken quicker than homemade.

The thickening of pudding in the fridge is a result of proteins and starches in the ingredients becoming increasingly concentrated over time.

To ensure the pudding sets up correctly, it is essential to follow the instructions on the pudding mix package or recipe accurately, as the amount of liquid added can affect how quickly the pudding thickens.

Too much liquid will delay the setting process, and too little can create a pudding that is overly thick and gummy.

If you are making a homemade pudding, you may let the pudding rest on the counter for a few minutes before transferring it to the refrigerator.

This will allow the starches and proteins to absorb some of the liquid before it is chilled.

Once in the fridge, give the pudding several hours to properly set up and thicken.

In conclusion, banana pudding can thicken in the fridge, though the time needed will depend on the type of pudding and recipe used.

It is important to follow instructions closely, including the amount of liquid added, as this will affect the pudding’s consistency.

Additionally, letting the pudding sit on the counter for a few minutes before transferring it to the fridge can help it to thicken more quickly.

How Do You Make Banana Pudding Thicker?

Banana pudding is a classic dessert that is easy to make and sure to be a hit with the whole family! However, it can sometimes become too thin and watery.

Fortunately, there are a few simple methods to thicken your banana pudding and make it the perfect consistency.

The most common way of thickening banana pudding is to add a thickening agent, such as cornstarch, arrowroot, or tapioca.

Simply mix the desired amount of your chosen thickening agent with a small amount of water until it is completely dissolved and then add it to your banana pudding mixture.

Stir the mixture and cook until it reaches the desired thickness.

Alternatively, you can reduce the liquid by simmering the pudding mixture over low heat until some of the liquid evaporates.

This will create a thicker and creamier consistency.

Finally, you can also add some extra ingredients to the pudding to make it thicker.

For instance, adding a few extra mashed bananas or a few tablespoons of instant pudding mix will help thicken the pudding.

You can also add some cream cheese or sour cream to give it a richer texture.

All in all, there are several easy ways to thicken banana pudding and make it just right.

Whether you choose to add a thickening agent, reduce the liquid, or add extra ingredients, you’ll be sure to have a delicious and creamy dessert in no time.

How Long Does It Take Banana Pudding To Get Thick?

The answer to how long it takes for banana pudding to thicken varies depending on a few factors.

If you’re making a cooked pudding, you’ll need to stir it frequently over medium heat for about 15 minutes, until it coats the back of a spoon.

For a no-cook pudding, the process should take about five minutes.

The ingredients you use also affect the consistency of pudding.

If you’re using a pudding mix, follow the instructions on the package for the amount of liquid you need.

If you’re using a recipe, the amount of starch (cornstarch or flour) will help the pudding thicken.

If you’re making a no-cook pudding, full-fat milk and cream will make the thickening process quicker.

In addition, the temperature of the ingredients affects how quickly the pudding thickens.

If you’re making a cooked pudding, the heat will activate the starch, speeding up the process.

For no-cook puddings, it’s best to use cold ingredients to ensure the pudding thickens quickly.

To summarize, a cooked pudding should take about 15 minutes to thicken and a no-cook pudding should take about five minutes.

The amount of starch, type of milk and cream, and temperature of the ingredients all impact the thickening time.

Will My Banana Pudding Thicken Overnight?

When it comes to whether banana pudding will thicken overnight, the answer is both yes and no.

If your recipe includes instant pudding mix, it can thicken due to thickeners such as modified cornstarch, gelatin and pectin, which create a thicker pudding consistency that will become even thicker as it sets in the refrigerator.

However, if your recipe does not include any thickeners, then it is unlikely that your pudding will thicken overnight since there is no chemical reaction taking place.

Similarly, if you are using a cooked banana pudding recipe, then the pudding can become thicker as it cools, but it is not likely to thicken overnight.

To check if your pudding will thicken overnight, it is important to review your recipe to determine if it contains any of the thickeners mentioned above.

If not, then try using a thicker base such as coconut milk, almond milk or cream.

Additionally, you can also add a small amount of cornstarch or arrow root powder to the banana pudding mix before chilling it overnight.

This will help to thicken the pudding and make it the perfect consistency for a delicious dessert.

Does Homemade Pudding Thicken When It Cools?

Homemade pudding does thicken when it cools, and this is due to a process known as starch retrogradation.

Starch molecules present in the pudding, such as cornstarch, arrowroot, or tapioca, become resistant to water and swell, resulting in a firmer texture.

When cooked, these starches gelatinize and absorb water, giving the pudding a smooth and creamy consistency.

As it cools, the starches become more resistant to moisture and the pudding thickens.

It is important to note that pudding will thicken gradually over time, and it’s best to let the pudding cool for at least an hour before serving.

If the pudding is left to cool too long, it can become too thick and difficult to work with.

To prevent this, you can whisk the pudding while it is cooling or add additional liquid to thin it out.

In summary, homemade pudding does thicken when it cools due to starch retrogradation.

For the best texture, it is important to let the pudding cool for the appropriate amount of time before serving.

How Long Does It Take For Pudding To Set?

The answer to this question depends on the type of pudding you’re making.

For instant puddings, all you need to do is mix the powder with the required liquid, and it’s ready to eat in minutes.

Cooked or homemade puddings, on the other hand, can take anywhere from 30 minutes to several hours to set, depending on the recipe.

You’ll know it’s done when it’s firm enough to hold its shape and doesn’t drip when you put a spoonful on a plate.

To test it, stick a knife or spoon into the pudding and see if it comes out clean.

If it does, it’s ready! Remember, patience is essential for the best results.

Does Pudding Set Up In The Fridge?

Yes, pudding can be refrigerated.

Pudding is a type of dessert that is made with a combination of milk, sugar, and cornstarch.

It is usually flavored with vanilla or chocolate, and can be served either warm or cold.

To make pudding, it should be cooked on the stove until it has a thick consistency.

Once it is cooked, it can be placed in the refrigerator to set and thicken.

Refrigerating pudding helps the cornstarch bind together, creating a thick and creamy texture.

Keep in mind that it can take up to 4 hours for the pudding to set.

If it is not refrigerated, the pudding will remain liquid and will not be able to set properly.

Pudding that has been refrigerated can be served cold or reheated in the microwave.

It can also be used as an ingredient in other desserts such as cakes and pies.

Pudding can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 5 days.

After this time, it should be thrown away.

In summary, pudding can be set in the fridge.

It is important to remember that it takes time for the pudding to set and that it should not be left out of the fridge for too long.

Reheating it in the microwave can help to restore its creamy texture.

Can You Put Pudding In The Fridge To Cool?

You can chill pudding in the refrigerator for a cool treat.

Make sure to store it in an airtight container to prevent absorbing any flavors from the fridge.

Depending on the type of pudding you’re using, you may need to stir or mix it after cooling.

Keep pudding away from strong-smelling foods as it can easily absorb odors.

Custard or mousse should be cooked and cooled quickly, so store them in the fridge to maintain their texture.

Put the pudding away from the back wall of the refrigerator as this part is usually the coldest, causing the pudding to become too stiff.

Pudding should be consumed within two to three days of chilling in the refrigerator.

Before eating, check the expiration date to ensure it is still safe to consume.

Can You Put Banana Pudding In Freezer To Set?

Yes, you can put banana pudding in the freezer to set quickly.

Instead of waiting a few hours for it to set in the refrigerator, putting it in the freezer can help speed up the process and get the pudding to a semi-solid state in just 20 minutes!

Before placing it in the freezer, however, make sure the pudding is already at least slightly cooled down.

If you put hot pudding in the freezer, it won’t set properly and you’ll end up with a runny mess.

Once the pudding has cooled down, you can freeze it for about 20-30 minutes.

After that, you can take it out and it should be set.

For best results, use a shallow container when freezing banana pudding.

This will help the pudding freeze more quickly and evenly.

Additionally, make sure to check on the pudding regularly while it’s in the freezer, as it can quickly go from being set to a solid block in just a few minutes.

By following these tips, you should have no problem getting your banana pudding to set in the freezer.

How Do You Know When Pudding Is Set?

Knowing when your pudding is set can be tricky, but it doesn’t have to be! Pay attention to the texture and look of the pudding to easily determine when it’s done.

One sign that your pudding is set is when a thin film forms on the surface.

Pull your spoon through the pudding and if the line formed by the spoon stays put, the pudding is set.

You can also look for signs of bubbling or boiling as an indication that it’s close to being done.

Check the texture of the pudding as well if it’s thick and there’s no liquid present, it’s done.

If it’s still runny, it needs more time to set.

For recipes that call for baking the pudding, insert a toothpick into the center and if it comes out clean, it’s ready.

The most accurate way to tell when pudding is set is to use a thermometer.

When the temperature reaches about 180F, it’s usually done.

Be sure not to overcook the pudding, as this will result in a rubbery texture rather than the creamy texture you’re looking for.

Final Thoughts

With these tips, you can make sure that your banana pudding turns out perfectly every time.

Next time your pudding is runny, take a look at the ingredients and techniques you used, and make the necessary adjustments.

You’ll be enjoying a delicious, creamy banana pudding in no time!


James has always been fascinated by fruit. Ever since he was a little kid, he was always the one asking questions about the different types of fruit and how they grow.He is always eager to share his knowledge with others, and loves talking about the different types of fruit, where they come from, and the best ways to prepare and eat them.

Recent Posts